Difference between revisions of "Talk:Coming-out story (trope)"
From Book Trigger Warnings
m (Jenjenreviews moved page Talk:Coming out (trope) to Talk:Coming-out story (trope): Changing name to be more fitting after discussion) |
m (cleaning up organization) |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
+ | ==Trope Name== | ||
I think Coming out is a bad name for this trope. If you really disagree with what I initially had it as Questioning is a better name than coming out. Coming out is something that people constantly do and this trope is mostly about the Questioning and figuring out your identity.-StrangenessBooks | I think Coming out is a bad name for this trope. If you really disagree with what I initially had it as Questioning is a better name than coming out. Coming out is something that people constantly do and this trope is mostly about the Questioning and figuring out your identity.-StrangenessBooks | ||
:We were initially confused with "coming-of-out" because we can't seem to find that as a term used anywhere but if you want to "coin" the term here, we're happy to do that. I also went to the website tvtropes.com and they seem to list this trope as [https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/ComingOutStory Coming-Out Story] so that's another option. Questioning on its own feels too broad for me. I'd prefer something like "Questioning sexuality/gender/etc." to make it more specific. Either way let us know how you feel because we're open to whatever. [[User:Jenjenreviews|Jenjenreviews]] ([[User talk:Jenjenreviews|talk]]) 16:08, 31 July 2020 (PDT) | :We were initially confused with "coming-of-out" because we can't seem to find that as a term used anywhere but if you want to "coin" the term here, we're happy to do that. I also went to the website tvtropes.com and they seem to list this trope as [https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/ComingOutStory Coming-Out Story] so that's another option. Questioning on its own feels too broad for me. I'd prefer something like "Questioning sexuality/gender/etc." to make it more specific. Either way let us know how you feel because we're open to whatever. [[User:Jenjenreviews|Jenjenreviews]] ([[User talk:Jenjenreviews|talk]]) 16:08, 31 July 2020 (PDT) | ||
− | Coming out is pretty vague as well. Coming-of-Out is combining of Coming of Age and Coming-Out because they often linked. I put it as trope since they're a lot talk about wanting stories beyond it (I've seen people rating down books because of it which a bit much for YA). "Questioning sexuality/gender/etc." is too long. I can't find another trope that is just "Questioning" in terms of trope names. I get using TV tropes as a guide but a lot of those tropes are made up as well. Coming-out story (trope) would be fine with me.-StrangenessBooks | + | ::Coming out is pretty vague as well. Coming-of-Out is combining of Coming of Age and Coming-Out because they often linked. I put it as trope since they're a lot talk about wanting stories beyond it (I've seen people rating down books because of it which a bit much for YA). "Questioning sexuality/gender/etc." is too long. I can't find another trope that is just "Questioning" in terms of trope names. I get using TV tropes as a guide but a lot of those tropes are made up as well. Coming-out story (trope) would be fine with me.-StrangenessBooks |
− | :Changing to Coming-out story (trope)! [[User:Jenjenreviews|Jenjenreviews]] ([[User talk:Jenjenreviews|talk]]) 23:22, 31 July 2020 (PDT) | + | :::Changing to Coming-out story (trope)! [[User:Jenjenreviews|Jenjenreviews]] ([[User talk:Jenjenreviews|talk]]) 23:22, 31 July 2020 (PDT) |
Latest revision as of 03:56, 10 August 2020
Trope Name
I think Coming out is a bad name for this trope. If you really disagree with what I initially had it as Questioning is a better name than coming out. Coming out is something that people constantly do and this trope is mostly about the Questioning and figuring out your identity.-StrangenessBooks
- We were initially confused with "coming-of-out" because we can't seem to find that as a term used anywhere but if you want to "coin" the term here, we're happy to do that. I also went to the website tvtropes.com and they seem to list this trope as Coming-Out Story so that's another option. Questioning on its own feels too broad for me. I'd prefer something like "Questioning sexuality/gender/etc." to make it more specific. Either way let us know how you feel because we're open to whatever. Jenjenreviews (talk) 16:08, 31 July 2020 (PDT)
- Coming out is pretty vague as well. Coming-of-Out is combining of Coming of Age and Coming-Out because they often linked. I put it as trope since they're a lot talk about wanting stories beyond it (I've seen people rating down books because of it which a bit much for YA). "Questioning sexuality/gender/etc." is too long. I can't find another trope that is just "Questioning" in terms of trope names. I get using TV tropes as a guide but a lot of those tropes are made up as well. Coming-out story (trope) would be fine with me.-StrangenessBooks
- Changing to Coming-out story (trope)! Jenjenreviews (talk) 23:22, 31 July 2020 (PDT)